BSCG takes Cairngorms local plan challenge to Court
- Details
- Written by Gus Jones
- Category: Debates
- Published: 26 January 2012
Following four days in the Court of Session in Edinburgh It is likely to be some months before we can expect the judgement of Lord Glennie in the case challenging the Cairngorms National Park Authority (CNPA) over the 2010 local Plan for the National Park. The case challengess a number of allocations in the local plan adopted by the Cairngorms National Park Authority (CNPA). The grounds include that the CNPA failed to take reasonable account of damaging environmental impacts, in spite of legal obligations including the founding legislation for National Parks in Scotland. The case was brought by BSCG jointly with the fellow environmental groups the Cairngorms Campaign and the Scottish Campaign for National Parks. All parties appeared grateful that the judge allowed extra time on the last day avoiding the delays and added expense of extending the proceedings to a later date.
Sir Crispin Agnew QC pesented the case for BSCG and our co appellants. Douglas Armstrong QC presented the response for the Cairngorms National Parks Authority. The Convener for the National Park Authority described the CNPA as defending the case “robustly”. James Findlay QC represented three further respondents ( developers and landowning interests) each involved with sites where housing allocation in the local plan could be quashed by the court.
One outcome we are hoping for is that allocations for new built development will be quashed. The allocations raised in the case are at Nethybridge, Carrbridge, Kingussie and An Camas Mor. The largest of these is the An Camas Mor 1500 house new town proposal in the Cairngorms National Scenic Area across the River Spey from Aviemore.
Another outcome of the judgement could be to clarify important matters of legal principle of general public interest; such as giving timely and due weight to environmental concerns in the planning process. We have consistently maintained that to deliver conservation objectives requires timely and realistic assessment of the likely environmental implications of developments, applying the precautionary principle whenever appropriate. At a top tier site we look for standards of governance sufficient to ensure that serious concerns including ones related to species that are known to be globally threatened are taken properly into account.
On the final day of the case the court discussed the possibility of a future hearing to deal with some matters that may require to be resolved depending on the findings of the Court.
In what can be viewed as a David and Goliath struggle we have been deeply heartened by the breadth of public support that we continue to receive. Without the generosity of literally hundreds of people and a number of organisations we would have been unable to take our case to court.
Needless to say BSCG and our co appellants consider our grievances amply merit the intense high level legal scrutiny to which they have now been subjected. We now hope the judgement when it comes will deliver positively for the environment conservation and the future of the Cairngorms area that is deservedly so special and dear to the hearts of so many.
The Heather shieldbug Rhacognathus punctatus
- Details
- Written by Gus Jones
- Category: Insects
- Published: 05 January 2012
The Heather shieldbug Rhacognathus punctatus on lowland heath woodland transition habitat with birch in Strathspey.
This is a local species that BSCG has since 2009 photographed on this threatened An Camas Mor site. In 1994 Stewart Taylor - whose contributions to conservation in the North of Scotland have been recognized by an MBE honour this year - recorded this bug in a clearing in Anagach wood. Currently Stewart Taylor's record is the only one for this bug available on the NESBReC website or on the National Biodiversity Network for the Cairngorms area.
AGM and Highland Wildcats Talk
- Details
- Written by Tessa Jones
- Category: Meetings
- Published: 01 November 2011
Photo: © Laurie Campbell
Illustrated Talk and Annual General Meeting
Tuesday 29 November 2011
Carrbridge Village Hall (in the smaller room)
AGM 7.00-7.45pm
Talk: ‘Helping the Highland Tiger – the Cairngorms Wildcat Project’ by Dr David Hetherington, 8.00pm
The AGM is for members only, but after the AGM we have an illustrated talk on that is open to anyone on the Cairngorms Wildcat Project starting at 8.00pm. The talk will be given by Dr David Hetherington who has been leading the project since it started a few years ago. The wildcat project now only has a few months to run and David will be telling us about the work of the project as well as future prospects for wildcat conservation.
More details to follow.
First in the UK Supreme Court
- Details
- Written by Gus Jones
- Category: Resources
- Published: 27 October 2011
Access to environmental justice is featured in the 2011 Autumn/ Winter issue of the Friends of the Earth supporters magazine 'What On Earth'
Friends of the Earth Scotland are understood to be the first Scottish NGO to intervene in a case at the UK Supreme Court. The organisation took the decision to intervene in a case involving pleural plaque sufferers. This case provided an opportunity to challenge the restrictive interpretation that courts in Scotland have sometimes placed on 'title and interest', which is the Scots Law test of standing: the right to have your case heard by the court. Despite supporting the involvement of the pleural plaque sufferers, the Scottish Government opposed Friends of the Earth Scotland's intervention.
Significantly the court ruling upheld the right of campaign groups to have cases heard in a Scottish court soley on public interest grounds.
Title and interest' has been an issue in a number of high-profile environmental cases in recent months such as when local resident, Molly Forbes, was deemed not to have 'title and interest' in her judicial review against Donald Trump and Aberdeenshire Council.
In championing access to environmental justice Friends of the Earth Scotland have called on the Scottish government to make it easier for breaches of environmental law and poor decisions to be challenged. Friends of the Earth Scotland is part of the largest grassroots environmental network in the world, uniting over 2 million supporters, 77 national member groups, and some 5,000 local activist groups - covering every continent. BSCG welcomes support from Friends of the Earth Scotland for our fight for environmental justice in the Cairngorms National Park.
Illustrated Talk: What Disturbs Capercaillie?
- Details
- Written by Gus Jones
- Category: Meetings
- Published: 17 September 2011
Cock capercaillie displaying in Strathspey
Illustrated Talk by Dr Robert Moss
Church Hall, Nethybridge, Wednesday 5th October 7.00pm
All welcome. Admission Free.
Please download, print and display event poster.